Netflix’s Risky Hollywood Play Overshadows Earnings

Netflix delivered a perfectly respectable final quarter, but the shares tumbled as the US market opened on Wednesday. The streaming giant posted a narrow earnings beat and hit 325 million subscribers, up 23 million since it last reported on the metric a year ago. Revenue landed slightly above expectations, helped by a strong content slate that included the final Stranger Things season. Under normal circumstances, this would be enough to give the stock a lift.

But these aren’t normal circumstances. Investors are far more focused on the looming Warner Bros Discovery deal and Netflix’s decision to suspend share buybacks to help fund it. Buybacks typically support a company’s share price; pausing them rarely wins applause. The message from Wall Street was clear: a decent quarter, but the risks ahead feel bigger.

And those risks are wrapped up in one of the messiest media M&A battles in years.

When M&A Negotiations Turn Ugly

Netflix is locked in a high‑stakes fight with Paramount Skydance over Warner Bros Discovery. After the Warner board initially backed Netflix’s offer, Paramount countered with a hostile $30‑per‑share all‑cash bid, appealing directly to shareholders. Netflix responded by abandoning its original cash‑and‑stock structure and switching to an all‑cash offer of $27.75 per share, valuing Warner Bros at $82.7 billion.

Netflix’s offer doesn’t include the cable networks, which would be spun off as Discovery Global, owned by Warner’s shareholders. Paramount’s offer is for the whole company.

At stake is nothing less than Hollywood’s crown jewels: Harry Potter, the DC Universe (including Superman and Batman), Game of Thrones, and a century of Warner Bros film and TV assets. For Netflix, a company that once prided itself on building rather than buying, this is a dramatic pivot, and a very expensive one.

Why Warner’s Board Prefers Netflix

Despite Paramount’s higher headline price, Warner’s board still argues that Netflix’s proposal is the safer, cleaner option. Paramount’s hostile bid expires today on January 21, and it’s unclear whether the company is going to continue the pursuit. The Warner board has consistently backed Netflix.

Netflix is Goliath: an investment‑grade company with a market cap of around $400 billion. Paramount is David: It plays in the junk‑bond league and has a $13 billion valuation.

But Paramount does have the Ellison factor: Its bid is backed by Oracle-billionaire Larry Ellison’s fortune, with his son David Ellison leading the company. Deep pockets alone don’t erase structural weaknesses, though, and the Warner board had to ask repeatedly before Larry Ellison provided an irrevocable personal guarantee for the deal in writing.

In short, Warner’s board believes Netflix offers certainty. Paramount offers drama.

Why Netflix Is Really Doing This: YouTube

The most revealing moment of Netflix’s earnings call had nothing to do with Warner Bros at all. Co‑CEO Ted Sarandos delivered a blunt assessment of the competitive landscape: YouTube has redefined television.

“TV is not what we grew up on. Oscars and the NFL are on YouTube,” he said. “Amazon owns MGM. Apple is competing for Emmys and Oscars, and Instagram is coming next.”

Netflix is no longer competing with just traditional studios — it’s competing with big tech in every dimension: talent, ad dollars, subscription dollars, and cultural relevance. The Warner Bros deal, he argued, is part of keeping pace in a new world where the definition of “TV” is being rewritten by platforms that didn’t exist a generation ago. Netflix is no longer the cool kid disrupting the industry. Instead it’s being disrupted.

This is the strategic heart of the acquisition. Netflix isn’t just buying a studio. It’s buying time. Time to stay ahead of YouTube, Amazon, Apple, and whatever Meta decides to do next.

Big Debt, Bigger Ambitions

If the merger is approved, the combined company would carry roughly $85 billion in debt, slightly less than a Paramount tie‑up would create. Netflix insists its investment‑grade credit rating and simplified all‑cash structure give Warner shareholders more certainty. Regulators, however, are expected to scrutinize the deal closely, and Netflix’s stock has taken a dive since the merger was announced, which likely accelerated the shift to an all‑cash bid.

Still, Netflix maintains that the long‑term payoff — theaters, franchises, and HBO’s brand power — will outweigh the short‑term pain. If Netflix is right, it will emerge as the undisputed heavyweight of global entertainment, for a while at least.

If it’s wrong, it will have paid nearly $83 billion to discover that it would have been better to keep building organically. Or the regulators block the deal, resulting in a stinging $5.8 billion breakup fee.

Either way, Hollywood hasn’t seen plot twists like these in a while, and the final act is still unwritten.

To learn more about how M&A deals work, download IBKR InvestMentor. No-nonsense, fun lessons about investing and the economy.